A moment someone shared with you

"You hold me responsible for our son"

When we hear an attack, we lose our needs; with giraffe ears we hear a shared need and a gift instead of an expectation.

  • Marshall Rosenberg
  • c. 2000
  • 3:20 min

Watch it free

Enter your email and we'll send you a link. It opens this clip, and the whole library of 100+ moments around it, for 24 hours.

No account, no password. The newsletter is optional, and leaving it unticked means we only send you this link.

Intro card: At the need level you have the same need. Where's the conflict? 3:20 · opens by email

Transcript

What Marshall says

A participant's ex-partner blames him for their son dropping out of college. Marshall shows that 'attacked' is an interpretation, not a feeling, and that the anger hides his needs. Hearing her disappointment instead, both turn out to want the same thing for their son, and the 'expectation' that he pay becomes a request he can answer honestly.

When you say that I'm responsible for my son dropping out of college and never going back. Okay, so when I hear you say things like, when my son, etc. and I've heard other comments from me of that genre. Okay, and how do you feel when this person says that? I feel defensive, I feel angry. Angry, angry. And you feel angry because why? I feel attacked. You interpret as an attack. It's not a feeling, it's an interpretation and that's why you're angry. You're angry because you interpret this as an attack. As criticism. What's the need? You'll have trouble finding the need because you're angry. You see, your head is so filled with those judgments, attack, criticism.

The rest is in the clip, subtitled.

Watch the whole clip free ↑

What's inside

Seven themes, one voice

Search by any word Marshall says, filter by theme, or press shuffle and let a clip find you.

Needs & feelings 24

What is alive in us, and what we long for

Empathy & listening 35

Giraffe ears, presence, hearing the person behind the words

Judgment, anger & guilt 28

Jackal thinking, inside and out, and what lies under it

Asking & saying no 20

Requests, demands, honesty and a giraffe's no

Gratitude & giving 14

Appreciation, and giving from the heart instead of duty

Love & family 28

Couples, parents, children, exes

Peace, power & society 31

Mediation, war, punishment, school and social change

“You don't have to guess right, we just have to guess human.”Marshall, in “You don't have to guess right”
“Every no is a poorly expressed yes.”Marshall, in “To say no in giraffe, never say no”
“We human beings, it doesn't take much to make life wonderful.”Marshall, in “A wink across the room”

Watch this clip ↑

The clips are archival recordings, cut and subtitled by NVC Rising. We don't own them; all rights belong to their owners. We share them so Marshall's voice keeps reaching people.

How the raffle works

  • On the first Monday of every month we draw three names from everyone who entered since the previous draw. Each entry takes part in exactly one draw.
  • The first name drawn wins free participation in the 2027 NVC Learning Community. The second and third each win €500 (or $500) off.
  • One entry per person per month. You need to be 18 or older. Entry to the raffle is free.
  • Already registered for the Learning Community? You can still win: your prize is applied as a refund of the difference.
  • Winners are notified by email and have 7 days to respond, otherwise we draw a new name.
  • Prizes are personal and cannot be paid out in cash.
  • This raffle is not sponsored, endorsed, or administered by Facebook or Meta.
  • Questions? Write to support@nvcrising.org.